Bear with me now: this one is theoretically gross but actually yummy. And it makes me giggle. I do girl parties all the time, and sometimes, it’s just fun to dive into something boy-ish and grody. And so I give you … shark chum Jell-O!

How to make Shark Chum Jell-O by The Party Teacher

What is chum? (Those are words I never expected to write on this blog…) Well, if you ever need to attract a shark, you toss chopped up bloody fish into the water. So my thought was chopped up Swedish Fish suspended in blue Jell-O. Gross. Giggle. Here’s how.

1 – Make blue Jell-O according to the package directions. Don’t make the quick-set version; stick with the four-hour version.

2 – Fill your individual containers one-third full with Jell-O. Put in the fridge for 40 minutes.

3 – In the meantime, cut most of your Swedish Fish into three pieces each.

Shark Chum Jell-O Tutorial - cut up Swedish Fish - The Party Teacher

4 – When your timer goes off, add three or four pieces of fish on top of the semi-set Jell-O. Fill it with another one-third layer of Jell-O. Put everything back in the fridge for 40 minutes more.

Shark Chum Jell-O Tutorial - make first layer of Jell-O - The Party Teacher

5 – Pull the Jell-O out and add another layer of chopped fish. Put one whole fish tail-first into the Jell-O, leaning its fishy head against the side of your container. Fill with remaining Jell-O so that the fish head is sticking out of the top. Refrigerate for three hours.

Shark Chum Jell-O Tutorial - position whole fish to stick up through the top - The Party Teacher

6 – Top with a few more fish pieces — a bright red, “bloody” garnish. Giggle.

Shark Chum Jell-O by The Party Teacher

7 – While you are waiting on the Jell-O to set, you can embellish some bamboo spoons. You don’t want the paint to go too far down the handle because it isn’t food safe. Take a bit of washi tape and wrap it around the handle. This will allow you to paint a clean line. When the paint is dry to the touch, remove the tape. When it is fully dry, add a strip of clean washi, and wrap it around the handle.

Shark party fork decorating tutorial by The Party Teacher

And that’s my own personal Shark Week. Miss a post? Make sure you see the Shark Fin Soda, Shark Tooth Rice Krispie Treats, and Shark Favor Balls. Did you do anything fun for Shark Week?

Shark Chum Jell-O by The Party Teacher

You Can Do It! Signature

Don't miss my FREE Party Planning Cheat Sheets!

Get the 8 worksheets I use to plan all my parties + my party prep checklist, day of the party schedule, and recommended party vendors.

Plus, you'll get all the latest blog posts from The Party Teacher.

(And of course, I'll never sell or share your email.)

You have successfully subscribed! Thanks for joining the party!

Pin It on Pinterest